Flicit Flicit Get Flicit
Language

Puzzles & Twists

Mind-Bending Movies That Reward a Second Watch: 14 Films

These are films that play with memory, time, identity or the way the story is told, and that look different the second time. We have kept every note spoiler-free, because with most of them, knowing the trick in advance takes something away. The table rates how hard each one is to follow, from a satisfying twist to a film people are still decoding decades later.

14 filmsFlicit editorialUpdated
How hard is it to follow?
FilmDifficultyWhat it plays with
RashomonEasyFour versions of one crime
The Sixth SenseEasyOne famous twist
Gone GirlEasyUnreliable narrators
The PrestigeMediumRival magicians, secrets
InceptionMediumDreams inside dreams
ArrivalMediumLanguage and time
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless MindMediumErased memories
MementoMediumTold backwards
Perfect BlueMediumReality and performance
CoherenceMediumOne dinner party, many versions
PredestinationMediumTime travel loops
EnemyHardA double, and a spider
Mulholland DriveHardDream logic in Hollywood
PrimerVery hardOverlapping timelines
Rashomon — poster

Rashomon (1950)

Directed by Akira Kurosawa

ClassicUnreliable witnessesShort

A samurai is dead and his wife assaulted in a forest, and four witnesses, including the dead man speaking through a medium, give four incompatible accounts. The film never says which is true. It is under ninety minutes and the root of every “unreliable narrator” film since.

Perfect Blue — poster

Perfect Blue (1997)

Directed by Satoshi Kon

AnimationPsychological thrillerAdults only

A pop idol quits her group to become an actress, and starts losing track of what is real as a stalker and a website that seems to know her thoughts close in. Satoshi Konʼs first film; its editing between reality, TV drama and delusion is still disorienting. Violent, with a sexual assault scene.

The Sixth Sense — poster

The Sixth Sense (1999)

Directed by M. Night Shyamalan

Ghost storyTwistGentle scares

A child psychologist tries to help a frightened young boy who says he sees dead people. It is better known for its ending than for anything else, but on a second watch it is a careful, sad film about grief. If somehow nobody has spoiled it for you, watch it now.

Memento — poster

Memento (2000)

Directed by Christopher Nolan

MemoryTold backwardsNoir

A man who canʼt form new memories hunts his wifeʼs killer using Polaroids, notes and tattoos. The color scenes run backwards, so you, like him, never know what just happened. Christopher Nolanʼs breakthrough, and more fun than it sounds once you get the rhythm.

Mulholland Drive — poster

Mulholland Drive (2001)

Directed by David Lynch

HollywoodDream logicUnsolved

An aspiring actress arrives in Los Angeles and finds a woman with amnesia hiding in her auntʼs apartment. For most of its length it is a strange but followable mystery, and then it isnʼt. David Lynch never explained it. Watch it for the mood and the audition scene, and donʼt expect a solution.

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind — poster

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004)

Directed by Michel Gondry

RomanceMemoryBittersweet

After a bad breakup, a man learns his ex had him erased from her memory, so he books the same procedure. Most of the film happens inside his head as the memories disappear around him. It is the most romantic film here, and one that people tend to see differently at thirty than at twenty.

Primer — poster

Primer (2004)

Directed by Shane Carruth

Time travelLow budgetVery hard

Two engineers building something in a garage accidentally make a box that lets them travel back a few hours, and start using it for the stock market. Made for about seven thousand dollars, full of technical talk, and famously almost impossible to follow on one viewing. Only 77 minutes.

The Prestige — poster

The Prestige (2006)

Directed by Christopher Nolan

MagiciansRivalryVictorian London

Two stage magicians in Victorian London try to ruin each other and steal each otherʼs best trick, at growing personal cost. The film is structured like a magic act, and tells you so at the start. With Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman and David Bowie as Nikola Tesla.

Inception — poster

Inception (2010)

Directed by Christopher Nolan

HeistDreamsBig screen

A team of thieves who steal ideas from peopleʼs dreams take a job planting one instead, which means going three dreams deep. The rules are explained clearly, so it is less confusing than its reputation. Best on the biggest screen and loudest speakers you have.

Coherence — poster

Coherence (2013)

Directed by James Ward Byrkit

Dinner partyLow budgetParallel worlds

Eight friends at a dinner party lose power while a comet passes overhead, and the house down the street starts to look very familiar. Mostly improvised, shot in one house in five nights, and more tightly plotted than films with a hundred times the budget. Pay attention to the glow sticks.

Predestination — poster

Predestination (2014)

Directed by Michael Spierig, Peter Spierig

Time travelParadoxBased on Heinlein

A time-traveling agent working undercover as a bartender in 1970s New York listens to a strangerʼs strange life story, and then offers him a chance at revenge. Based on a Robert Heinlein short story. The less you know going in, the better; it is more of a character drama than an action film.

Gone Girl — poster

Gone Girl (2014)

Directed by David Fincher

ThrillerMarriageDark comedy

On their fifth anniversary, a manʼs wife disappears, and as the media descends, he starts to look guilty. It is less a puzzle than a series of rug-pulls about what you believe and who you trust, and much funnier, in a very dark way, than you expect.

Enemy — poster

Enemy (2013)

Directed by Denis Villeneuve

DoppelgängerTorontoUnsettling

A history professor spots an actor who looks exactly like him in a rented film, and tracks him down. Jake Gyllenhaal plays both men in a hazy, yellow Toronto. Short, unsettling and built around a final shot that people are still arguing about.

Arrival — poster

Arrival (2016)

Directed by Denis Villeneuve

Science fictionLanguageMoving

When twelve alien ships appear around the world, a linguist is brought in to work out how to talk to them. It is a first-contact film about grammar, grief and time, told patiently, with a structure that only makes full sense at the end. The rare puzzle film that also makes people cry.

Posters and film data from TMDB. This site uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.

Keep a record of what you watch.

Add the film, your viewing date and a few words to your private movie journal.

Get Flicit on the App Store